Profs and Pints DC presents: “Legal Guardrails for Trump 2.0,” an examination of where laws and the judiciary offer checks to overreach by Donald Trump’s incoming administration, with Scott Michelman, Legal Director of the ACLU-D.C. and lecturer on law and Shikes Fellow in Civil Liberties and Civil Rights at Harvard Law School.

In a time of political uncertainty and increasing threats to civil liberties, it’s more important than ever to understand how our democracy and civil rights are protected. Join Scott Michelman, a veteran law-school teacher and civil-rights lawyer who has litigated cases from the Supreme Court on down, for an insightful discussion of how we can defend our freedoms and what the courts can—and can’t—do to protect us.

You’ll get a crash course on various checks on presidential power and on areas where presidents have substantial leeway. Michelman will talk about specific threats to our rights, including free speech, the right to protest, the potential for domestic military deployment, retaliatory prosecution, and the creation of a new “Schedule F” to reclassify federal employees as political appointees to make it easier to fire them. He’ll highlight how the lack of statehood leaves the District vulnerable to congressional interference. He’ll discuss how historically oppressed communities’ civil rights and civil liberties may be impacted and what steps are being taken to defend them.

You’ll learn how courts’ powers to invalidate executive actions are limited in areas where the president has broad discretion, such as deploying the military, enforcing immigration laws, or using federal forces for crowd control. In response to President-elect Trump’s stated willingness to use military forces during protest, Michelman will provide an in-depth discussion on protest rights, including your rights have when interacting with law enforcement, and how to document potential abuses of police power. (Advance tickets: $13.50 plus sales tax and processing fees. Doors: $17, or $15 with a student ID. Listed time is for doors. Talk starts 30 minutes later.)

Image: An official White House photo shows President Donald J. Trump walking from the White House to St. John’s Episcopal Church in June 2020. Police had used riot-control tactics to clear protesters and members of the media from his path.

Event Date

Tuesday, January 14, 2025 - 6:00pm

Featured image

More information / register

Venue

Penn Social

Address

801 E St NW
Washington, DC 20004
United States

Tiles

Image

headshot of Scott Michelman

Name

Scott Michelman

Supporting text

Legal Director

Title

Speaker

Tweet Text

[node:title]

Date

Tuesday, January 14, 2025 - 6:00pm

Menu parent dynamic listing

43455

As everyone who lives in, works in, or visits D.C. knows, the District has long been a critical venue where people express their political views. The great majority of demonstrators in D.C. do not encounter problems when protesting. The First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution protects “the freedom of speech” as well as “the right of the people peaceably to assemble.” That means you have a constitutional right to demonstrate (although how, when, and where you demonstrate can be restricted; read more here).

Still, it pays to be prepared, especially if you plan to risk arrest. Here are five things to know about protesting in D.C.

1. D.C. has both local and federal territory, and the rules are different, so know which one you are protesting in.

Metro stations and D.C. streets and sidewalks are local territory. All green space downtown (even small parks), the National Mall, federal buildings/monuments (and nearby sidewalks), and Rock Creek Park are federal land.

Also, D.C. has four quadrants: NW, NE, SE, and SW. They meet at the Capitol. Most federal monuments and federal buildings are on and around the National Mall, which divides NW from SW. If you see an address, pay attention to the quadrant!

2. Getting a permit for your demonstration is often a good idea, but it is not always required.

Getting a permit reserves your location and alerts police to your demonstration. Rules and procedures vary based on location and whether you are in local or federal territory.

If you want to demonstrate on local territory, permitting is governed by D.C. law. D.C. calls protests “First Amendment Assemblies.” No notice or approval is needed if:

  • the protest won’t block pedestrians from using sidewalks and crosswalks; or
  • if attendance will be under 50 and won’t be on a D.C. street; or
  • if the assembly breaks out spontaneously.

If you want to demonstrate on federal land, permitting is governed by National Park Service regulations. You’ll generally need a permit to demonstrate on federal land if you have 25 or more people, although there are exceptions in certain places. For example, up to 500 people are allowed to demonstrate without a permit at Franklin Park (13th & K St NW) or McPherson Square (15th & K St NW). If you want to demonstrate on the U.S. Capitol Grounds, permitting is governed by Capitol Police regulations. You’ll need a permit if you have 20 or more people, and the locations for demonstrations are limited. Even if it’s not required, giving notice and getting approval via a permit can be a good idea. For more on permits, visit acludc.org/permits.

3. Many different kinds of police patrol protests in D.C., so get to know law enforcement badges.

Metro stations and local D.C. streets and sidewalks are mainly policed by the D.C. Metropolitan Police Department (MPD) and Metro Transit Police.

All green space downtown (even small parks), the National Mall, federal buildings/monuments (and nearby sidewalks), and Rock Creek Park are mainly policed by Park Police, Federal Protective Service, Capitol Police, and the Secret Service.

Which police you see will depend on where you are. Get to know the arm patches for the major police departments and agencies so you can recognize them. For pictures of badges, go to https://www.acludc.org/en/know-your-rights/know-your-rights-demonstrations-dc.

4. There are steps you can take to prepare to encounter police at protests.

For example, if you are planning to engage in civil disobedience or are participating in a demonstration where arrests are likely, you may want to:

  • carry $100 cash and three days’ worth of essential medications, in their original bottles;
  • make emergency childcare plans if you have young children;
  • put a password on your phone to protect against searches; and
  • memorize or write on your arm phone numbers for your family, your lawyer, and jail support.

If you are not a U.S. citizen (and especially if you are undocumented), under court supervision, or have a record, talk to a lawyer about the risks of arrest before protesting. The consequences can be worse for you than other people.

If you are a person with a disability, special medical needs, or limited English, carry a card or wear a bracelet to explain your situation, should the need arise.

If you are gender non-conforming, the D.C. Metropolitan Police Department, U.S. Park Police, and U.S. Capitol Police are all supposed to respect gender designations on driver’s licenses, so have an accurate license if possible.

5. You do not have to answer a police officer’s questions or provocations, and it’s usually safer if you don’t.

When interacting with police at D.C. protests, it’s important to try to de-escalate the situation if you can. For instance, you can respond to an officer’s statements with generic, polite responses. If an officer asks, “What are you doing?” You can simply answer, “I’m attending a protest.”

If officers continue to ask questions or otherwise make you uncomfortable, ask, “Am I free to leave?” This phrase will help you find out if it is permissible for you to end the interaction. If the officer says yes, calmly and silently walk away. If the officer says no, you’ve been stopped and have to stay where you are.

In case of a stop, you can ask, “Am I under arrest?” If the officer says yes, ask, “For what crime?” If the interaction continues, say, “I wish to remain silent,” and repeat the phrase if questioning continues.

If asked, you should give your name and address to an officer, but do not give any additional information, excuses, or explanations. Generally, Metropolitan Police Department officers cannot force you to give them your I.D. at a protest. But federal law enforcement officials can require non-citizens to show proof of their lawful status. If you are a non-citizen, carry documents demonstrating your status.

If arrested, you should say, “I wish to remain silent. I want a lawyer.” Know that the police can lie to you (if, for example, they promise you’ll get out faster if you answer questions). Don't sign anything you do not understand, especially any papers stating that you understand and want to waive your rights.

For more information on what to know before, during, and after protests in D.C., check out our Know Your Rights guide for demonstrators in D.C. And if you believe that your First Amendment rights have been violated in the District of Columbia, contact us.

Date

Monday, January 6, 2025 - 5:00pm

Featured image

KNOW YOUR RIGHTS.

Show featured image

Hide banner image

Tweet Text

[node:title]

Related issues

Freedom of Speech and Association

Show related content

Menu parent dynamic listing

43459

Show PDF in viewer on page

Style

Centered single-column (no sidebar)

Show list numbers

Pages

Subscribe to ACLU of DC RSS