We represented an anonymous internet blogger whose colorful language about politicians (e.g., “He’s a slimy political animal. Let’s put him down.”) apparently caught the attention of a Capitol Police internet search bot, resulting in a grand jury subpoena to the blogger’s internet host (WordPress) seeking his identity. We filed a motion to intervene and to quash the subpoena, arguing that the First Amendment protects anonymous political speech and that the blog, read as a whole, made clear that the author was making political commentary, not threats. A few weeks after we filed, the government informed the court that the subpoena had been withdrawn, and our motion was dismissed as moot. We then filed a motion to unseal the court filings—all papers dealing with grand jury proceedings are automatically under seal—which was granted, and the papers were placed on the public docket (No. 11-mc-362 (D.D.C.)).
In re Grand Jury Subpoena No. 10218019
Pro Bono Law Firm(s)
Zuckerman Spaeder LLP
Date filed
June 23, 2011
Status
Victory!
Related Issues
Related content

Federal Appeals Court Strikes Down Political Speech Restrictions on...
August 16, 2022Civil Rights Groups Push for Appeal to Hold Federal Officials...
April 20, 2022In Partial Settlement of Civil Rights Suits on Behalf of...
April 13, 2022Lafayette Square Attack Timeline
April 12, 2022ACLU-DC Responds to Verdict in Kyle Rittenhouse Case
November 19, 2021